What’s up with the Five-Star Quality Rating System

by | May 9, 2022 | Five Star & Quality

Explore More Posts from MDS Consultants

What’s up with the Five-Star and Care Compare?

The Nursing Home Compare Five-Star Quality Rating System was developed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to assist residents and their families with information to “understand assessment of nursing home quality.”  The domains of the Five-Star Quality Rating System are

  • State Health Inspections
  • Staffing and
  • Quality Measures

Recently CMS upgraded and renamed Nursing Home Compare to Care Compare – but many places still refer to Nursing Home Compare.

Health Inspections – Five-Star Quality Rating System

The State-Level Health Inspection Cut Point table was recently updated. According to the April 2022 Nursing Home Compare Five-Star Quality Rating System: Technical Users’ Guide State-Level Health Inspection Cut Point Table (released April 27, 2022), “the cut points for the staffing ratings and for the QM ratings have been fixed and do not vary monthly.” Having the most current technical user’s guide will assist the organization’s leadership in identifying what has to happen based on the “cut points” to improve the domain star rating.

Staffing – Care Compare information:

Organization’s turnover rates are now being publicly reported on Nursing Home Compare/Care Compare but are not currently used in the Five-Star Quality Rating System. CMS warns that when an employee identifier (employee ID) is changed in Payroll Based Journal (PBJ) it influences turnover calculations. The same employee with two different employee ID’s appears to CMS as two different employees, not one.

Per Linking Methodology, if a facility does not follow proper steps, “it will artificially increase its staff turnover measures (i.e., viewed as worse performance)”. For facilities changing employee identifiers, please refer to the linking methodology document to prevent this from happening.

Quality Measures – Five-Star Quality Rating System

According to Design for Care Compare Nursing Home Five-Star Quality Rating System: Technical Users’ Guide, effective with the April 2022 refresh, CMS is implementing planned, regular increases to the Quality Measure (QM) rating thresholds, increasing each rating threshold by one-half of the average improvement in QM scores since the last time the thresholds were set.

For the April 2022 refresh, the average improvement is determined from the period of April 2019 – January 2022. The new rating thresholds are shown in Table 6 of this document. Note that the point thresholds for individual QMs are not changing (p.iii).”

For additional guidance, review a memo provided by CMS to State Survey Directors – QSO-19-08-NH.

Due to this change to the rating threshold, an organization’s star rating can change without changes in data submitted at the time of the refresh. This change focuses on continuous quality improvement, and facilities should continue to be on the lookout for regularly scheduled changes.

Some take-aways to consider:

  • Ensure your organization’s guides are up to date.
  • Review Five Star preview reports in QIES as they become available
  • Update the interdisciplinary team regarding changes involved in the domains supporting the organization’s Five-Star Quality Rating System and Care Compare.
  • Monitor and analyze trends on a consistent basis and update plans for continuous improvement.

Resources

Design for Care Compare Nursing Home Five-Star Quality Rating System: Technical Users’ Guide. Nursing Home Compare Technical Users’ Guide (cms.gov)

Nursing Home Compare Five-Star Quality Rating System: Technical Users’ Guide State-Level Health Inspection Cut Point Table. Star cut points for health inspection scores by state – Updated April 2022 (cms.gov)

QSO-19-08-NH. QSO19-08-NH (cms.gov)

Changing Employee Identifiers (ID) in the Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) System. Changing Employee Identifiers (ID) in the Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) System (cms.gov)

Care Compare. Find Healthcare Providers: Compare Care Near You | Medicare

 

Explore More Posts from MDS Consultants

Get ready for October 1

Transportation – New Item A1250

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of October 1, 2023 What You Can Expect to See An additional item we will see in the upcoming MDS 3.0 v.1.18.11 in October 2023 is A1250 - Transportation. This is included in a new subset of...

New 3-day Lookbacks | Assessment Periods

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of March 24, 2023 What You Can Expect to See New 3-day lookback/assessment periods are coming to the MDS world. There are different sections of the MDS that the Nurse Assessment Coordinators...

New Pain Interview in Section J

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of February 22, 2023 What You Can Expect to See The most noticeable changes to Section J are evident in the pain interview, specifically questions J0510, J0520 and J0530. The RAI Manual has...

Section B – Hearing, Speech and Vision Changes

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of October 1, 2023 What You Can Expect to See Section B on the MDS is a component of the Standardized Patient Assessment Data Elements (SPADEs), which is utilized across post-acute care...

Race and Ethnicity – Changes in Section A

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of October 1, 2023 What You Can Expect to See Section A, Identification Information for Race/Ethnicity has expanded. One of the major changes is the deletion of section A1000 Race/Ethnicity....

Read more on Toolbox Essentials

Focused Infection Control Surveys and Directed Plan of Correction

It's a dreary Monday morning, and the state surveyors walk into your facility to conduct a Focused Infection Control survey. You and your team have been trying your hardest to comply with infection control procedures throughout the pandemic. At the end of the survey,...

New Advanced Beneficiary Notice

Is your facility using the proper ABN form? The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently updated the Advanced Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage (ABN), Form CMS-R-131. The new ABN will be mandatory for use on 1/1/2021, but the new form can be...

Covid-19 and Skilled Status

In late June, CMS addressed two issues and posted MDS 3.0 Final Item Sets (V1.17.2).  The two edits were changes to facilitate the calculation of Patient-Driven Payment Model payment codes on OBRA assessments for states that wish to have this calculation performed. ...

Mind Your PHQs

Some skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) are concerned about accurate payment when a resident unexpectedly discharges and the Brief Interview for Mental Status (BIMS) has not yet been completed.However, they should be just as concerned about the PHQ-9. The PHQ-9...

MDS in the Emergency Preparedness Plan

The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the need for skilled nursing facilities to have an effective Emergency Preparedness Plan - one that includes sheltering-in-place. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Final Rule requires that participating providers have an...

MORE from MDS Experts

Coding UTIs on the MDS 3.0

Urinary Tract Infections (UTIs) are a commonly miscoded data element on the MDS. Are you over coding UTIs? Are you not coding them at all? Should you? Shouldn’t you? The MDS has historically left data collectors asking themselves these questions. What happens if I do...

Achieving Accurate ADLs with the OSA

Section G of the MDS 3.0 was retired October 1, 2023, yet the MDS nurse may still need to use the knowledge of accurately coding ADLs with an assessment called the Optional State Assessment (OSA).  State-Optioned OSA Although the option to choose an OSA from the...

What Is an MDS Coordinator?

It’s a bit odd that when asked what you do for a living most MDS coordinators struggle to come up with an answer. Who struggles to explain what they do every day? The reality is that MDS Coordinators fully understand what this multifaceted job entails, but are at a...

MDS 2023 Countdown Wrap-Up

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer: Current as of May 13, 2023.   What You Can Expect to See CMS released the first MDS draft item set (v1.18.11) in September 2022, which generated many questions for the long-term care community. Both...

Rx Reconciliation – New SNF QRP and QMs

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of October 1, 2023 What You Can Expect to See The reconciled medication list will have a new documentation requirement that will go into effect with the October 1, 2023 changes to the MDS...

Webinars & Training

Grow your knowledge with our MDS education

MDS Guides & Forms

Exclusive resources & tools we use every day

Ask an Expert Forum

Members can get 1:1 advice from our MDS experts

Let's Meet in Person

Get more info on our training & conference schedule

News for MDS Experts

Browse our blog & get news alerts on MDS changes

MDS Completion

Get your MDS' done ASAP with short-term, expert help

Remote Floater

Fill gaps on your team when & where you need

Case Mix Index

Improve your complex case mix calculations

MDS System Mgt

Best practices for MDS schedules & workflow

+ More Services

Get help on PDPM, ICD-10, quality, schizoph. audits ++