Updates to the Staffing Five Star

CMS released revisions to the staffing methodology in July through an updated Design for Care Compare Nursing Home Five-Star Quality Rating System: Technical Users’ Guide July 2022. The staffing star rating includes expanded from two to six compenents and introduced a new scoring calculation.

The updated Five Star rating is calculated from the following six staffing measures:

  • Case-mix adjusted total nurse (RN, LPN/LVN, aide) staffing levels (hours per resident per day)
  • Case-mix adjusted RN staffing levels (hours per resident per day)
  • Case-mix adjusted total nurse (RN, LPN/LVN, aide) staffing levels (hours per resident per day) on the weekend  
  • Total nurse turnover, defined as the percentage of nursing staff that left the nursing home over a twelve-month period
  • Registered Nurse (RN) turnover, defined as the percentage of RN staff that left the nursing home over a twelve-month period
  • Administrator turnover, defined as the number of administrators who left the nursing home over a twelve-month period

Each measure is assigned points “based on the performance” by the facility, then the points from the six measures are summed. The summed score makes up the organization’s “total staffing score.” The total staffing score is “compared to staffing rating point thresholds to assign a rating of one to five stars.”The revised staffing measure compilation mirrors the quality measure star rating in configuration.

Another change is the impact of the staffing star rating on the overall Five Star for an organization. The staffing star rating needs to be a five-star to potentially add a star to the organization’s overall rating (unless already at an overall five-star). This is a change from prior rules, when a 4 star or 5 star rating would add a star to the overall score.

The case-mix adjusted staffing measures continue to use the daily resident census derived from the minimum data set (MDS) and the Resource Utilization Group (RUG-IV) case-mix system. A review of how all the components work together to turn the case-mix adjusted hours into stars is covered in the technical user guide.

The Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) system continues to be the source of reported staffing hours. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has required nursing homes to submit data using the PBJ since 2016.

In addition to the most recent release of the July 2022 Technical User Guide, the memorandum QSO-22-08-NH is worth a read to review ways to ensure accurate PBJ data and linked employee IDs – which could negatively affect turnover measures used in the Five Star rating.

We recommend that a review of an organization’s star ratings should be part of the organization’s QAPI/QAA process. A systematic systemic review of the nursing home’s star rating by the QAPI/QAA committee might include:

  • Identify an interdisciplinary team to review the data now and on a scheduled time determined by the team’s analysis of the initial review.
  • Conduct a review of each component’s configuration and the organizational practices to support the data.
  • Update any practices found deficient in accurately reporting data and implement a plan for monitoring.
  • Evaluate the need for a performance improvement project (PIP) if staffing in the organization needs improvement.
  • Ensuring CMS has accurate data is only the beginning. Building an organizational culture that focuses on and understands how staffing is measured in the nursing home industry will be key moving forward.




Explore More Posts from MDS Consultants

Get ready for October 1

Transportation – New Item A1250

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of October 1, 2023 What You Can Expect to See An additional item we will see in the upcoming MDS 3.0 v.1.18.11 in October 2023 is A1250 - Transportation. This is included in a new subset of...

New 3-day Lookbacks | Assessment Periods

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of March 24, 2023 What You Can Expect to See New 3-day lookback/assessment periods are coming to the MDS world. There are different sections of the MDS that the Nurse Assessment Coordinators...

New Pain Interview in Section J

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of February 22, 2023 What You Can Expect to See The most noticeable changes to Section J are evident in the pain interview, specifically questions J0510, J0520 and J0530. The RAI Manual has...

Section B – Hearing, Speech and Vision Changes

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of October 1, 2023 What You Can Expect to See Section B on the MDS is a component of the Standardized Patient Assessment Data Elements (SPADEs), which is utilized across post-acute care...

Race and Ethnicity – Changes in Section A

This post is part of the MDS 2023 Countdown series.  Disclaimer. Current as of October 1, 2023 What You Can Expect to See Section A, Identification Information for Race/Ethnicity has expanded. One of the major changes is the deletion of section A1000 Race/Ethnicity....

Read more on Toolbox Essentials

Focused Infection Control Surveys and Directed Plan of Correction

It's a dreary Monday morning, and the state surveyors walk into your facility to conduct a Focused Infection Control survey. You and your team have been trying your hardest to comply with infection control procedures throughout the pandemic. At the end of the survey,...

New Advanced Beneficiary Notice

Is your facility using the proper ABN form? The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently updated the Advanced Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage (ABN), Form CMS-R-131. The new ABN will be mandatory for use on 1/1/2021, but the new form can be...

Covid-19 and Skilled Status

In late June, CMS addressed two issues and posted MDS 3.0 Final Item Sets (V1.17.2).  The two edits were changes to facilitate the calculation of Patient-Driven Payment Model payment codes on OBRA assessments for states that wish to have this calculation performed. ...

Mind Your PHQs

Some skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) are concerned about accurate payment when a resident unexpectedly discharges and the Brief Interview for Mental Status (BIMS) has not yet been completed.However, they should be just as concerned about the PHQ-9. The PHQ-9...

MDS in the Emergency Preparedness Plan

The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the need for skilled nursing facilities to have an effective Emergency Preparedness Plan - one that includes sheltering-in-place. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Final Rule requires that participating providers have an...

MORE from MDS Experts

New Year….Same MDS Obstacle Course

As we ring in 2024, long term care professionals are still struggling to implement the October 2023 updates to the MDS. CMS is already talking about more changes in 2024, and the anticipation continues to create anxiety amongst PAC members. While the full...

Schizophrenia Diagnosis Audits

On January 18th, 2023, CMS announced they will be conducting off-site audits in nursing homes for assessment accuracy and coding of residents with a diagnosis of Schizophrenia. Along with auditing for appropriate diagnosis, the audits will review appropriate use of...

OSA or PDPM? A State-Level Decision

As of Oct. 1, 2023, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has retired the A0300 Optional State Assessment (OSA) from the federally required MDS 3.0 v1.18.11 that is submitted by nursing facilities. The OSA is now a separate optional MDS assessment...

The Physician and “I”

The physician’s role in the nursing facility is essential to delivering skilled, quality care for Skilled and Long-Term Care residents. Physicians are our lead in providing clinical decision making and properly defining, clarifying, and verifying diagnoses. Only the...

Coding UTIs on the MDS 3.0

Urinary Tract Infections (UTIs) are a commonly miscoded data element on the MDS. Are you over coding UTIs? Are you not coding them at all? Should you? Shouldn’t you? The MDS has historically left data collectors asking themselves these questions. What happens if I do...

Webinars & Training

Grow your knowledge with our MDS education

MDS Guides & Forms

Exclusive resources & tools we use every day

Ask an Expert Forum

Members can get 1:1 advice from our MDS experts

Let's Meet in Person

Get more info on our training & conference schedule

News for MDS Experts

Browse our blog & get news alerts on MDS changes

MDS Completion

Get your MDS' done ASAP with short-term, expert help

Remote Floater

Fill gaps on your team when & where you need

Case Mix Index

Improve your complex case mix calculations

MDS System Mgt

Best practices for MDS schedules & workflow

+ More Services

Get help on PDPM, ICD-10, quality, schizoph. audits ++